Every industry leader in guitar manufacturing uses either solid-state technology, vacuum tube technology, or a blend of both to build amps. Some amps feature integrated digital technology to reproduce the sound of different amps, which can be solid-state or tube. Selecting the best amp for your guitar? It can get pretty confusing. We’ve done the research on Tube Amps VS. Solid State to let help you.
There are a few interchangeable terms you should be familiar with. When discussing tubers, the term “valve” might also appear, especially if British amplifiers such as Vox or Marshall is concerned. There is virtually no difference between valves and tubes.
The important thing here is differentiating between a tube amp and a solid-state amp. Let’s take a look.
A Glimpse into the History of Guitar Amplifiers
Tubes have been used in music since Thomas Edison lived. Before the World War II, tubes were an indispensable part of the design of electronic amplifiers. This included telephone, radio, and early television technology.
Transistor technology was invented in the late ‘40s, and over the next thirty years, most of the tube-dependent systems made the transition to transistors.
Interestingly enough, guitar amplifiers are a rare case where the old is better than the new. Meaning tubes continue to be a better option than transistors.
Tube Amps VS. Solid State: Differences Between Tube Amps and Solid State
Tube amps came first. They are driven by voltage whereas a solid-state amp uses current across the output devices to function. Voltage cannot drive a speaker by itself, thus the need for output transformers. The majority of stereo tube amps feature three big, heavy objects, generally at the back. Those are two output transformers and a power transformer (one for each specific channel) that transform the voltage to current.
Generally, a solid-state amp includes a single power transformer but no output transformer. With that said, a tube and a solid-state output transistor achieve the same targets. Here, the difference is that one does it encapsulated in silicone with current while the other performs it from a glass vacuum using voltage.
Time for the big question. Do they sound different? They do. However, some solid-state amps have a strong tube-like sound and some companies will intentionally make their tube amps produce a more solid-state sound (for power).
In comparison to a tube amp, a solid-state amp requires lesser maintenance and upkeep.
Returning to the sound, we would like to mention that tube amps do feature a controlled and sound bass. There’s a popular myth that they can’t and this is far from the truth. Like with any other product, everything has its distinct color and voicing. What are the general benefits of each?
Tubes have greater texture and more realism in the instruments and vocals, a rich midrange; a larger sense of bloom, if you would. Solid-state amps offer more watts for each dollar, better detail, and faster sound. Keep in mind that these are all generalizations.
If your system is somewhat fatiguing or harsh, chances are, you would love having a tube amp. If the system is sluggish, flat, or sounds too soft, on the other hand, a high-quality solid-state amp could save it. One other important factor is speaker load. Although rarer in today’s market, some speakers need a super low impedance driving capacity plus tons of power. Under these circumstances, you would be better off with a solid-state amp.
Alternatively, if the speakers are of standard efficiency and have an average impedance curve, get a tube amp to elevate your audio system.
Tube Amps VS. Solid State Amp: Which One Is Better for You?
When you’re trying to fix on one, consider your requirements. You should be realistic – practical about your priorities. We understand that it’s easy to get swayed by seeing your favorite guitar use one or seeing people give their opinion in forums, but in the end, your tone comes from you. Here’s the bitter truth: A lot of the times, the “aura” resonating off a particular amplifier is nothing more than the hype built around it. They could simply be overrated.
In this case, you have to let your wallet make the decision. Unless you have some extra cash you can splurge on a top-notch amp, you could get a budget option that works fine. For young players who are still getting into the industry, beginner-friendly affordable options are lifesavers.
Some other considerations that may help you make the decision:
A Tube Amp Is the Way to Go When:
- You can perform the upkeep: Tubes are tricky to handle. These are simply filaments like light bulbs, which also means that they can cause signal or noise loss or burn out.
- You think it will add value to your playing sessions
- Tube tone is what you were looking for.
- It’s within your budget.
Go for the Solid-State Amp If:
- You don’t want to burn a hole in your pocket by buying an amp.
- You’re a garage or bedroom hobby player.
- You need a dependable rig as a gigging musician.
- You’ve tried tube amps but the solid-state amp calls to you.
The Final Verdict
To us, tube amps reign superior. But then again, this is our perception.
There is an entire community of hobby players who wouldn’t trade their solid-state amps for anything. And there’s nothing wrong with that.
You can find a few great tube amp options with great price tags on the market today, so you’re not essentially going to go bankrupt to get the perfect tube tone. When it comes to gear for your guitar, it’s best to do what makes you happy. Different players are accustomed to different kind of amps, and they know how to create excellent sound from every kind of gear. What we’re saying is that you can go against the grain and create something beautiful out of it if you wanted to.
Hopefully, you now have a clear idea about Tube Amps VS. Solid State . Figure out your needs and go ahead with that.
You can also read: Apple AirPods: Answering Calls and Making Them